May 27, 2010

Show and Tell

While browsing the TV channels few hours ago I came across an ad for a new TV show "Baat Humari pakki Hai" 
Here's the promo that intrigued me,
It is hardly a minute long but still there is so much wrong here, or I should say there is hardly anything in it that is right!
Wow! We are telling our girls that

  • they should not play in the sun or their complexion will darken and no one would marry them, 
  • they need to learn to cook to get married
  • they need not focus on their academics because once they get married only housework knowledge will come handy and 
after all this when the time comes the ball is still in the guy's court as the woman in the video puts it  "hum ladka dekhney nahi ladki dikhaney jaa rahe hain" (we are not going to see the boy but to show our girl) . So what we are basically saying  is ......If the guy likes you, you should not have the nerve to say no because you cannot and your opinion does not matter, why? because you were raised to get married and not ask questions, not express your likes and dislikes, you need to be thankful that he, who came to see you, has approved you and if he doesn't like you, better go check the mirror, there's got to be something wrong about you and we as a family are doomed. You are an object of this Show and Tell, where we show and they tell and you endure. And if you want any of this to change, hope to be born as a man next time.
                    This is where we have reached after claiming bragging rights for Jhansi ki rani who led a battle, Sarojini Naidu who was the president of Indian National Congress and later on became the first female governor in India, Kamaljit Sandhu who won a Gold in Asian games for India, Kalpana Chawla who went to space, Indira Gandhi, Pratibha Patil and many unknown women who are achieving what they aspire. The list of women who went on to do something with their lives other than just getting married is endless and we all are proud of them. When we present our country anywhere else in the world, we do not shy away and rather flaunt about these facts, we love to tell everyone that ours is a progressive country with equal rights and opportunities for men and women. Is it really the reality? When the time comes for us to participate in that progress, when we get a chance to empower our girls, what do we do in our homes? We give them a rolling pin and a fairness creme.
                                    A friend in college was once told by her boyfriend that when you see my mom I want you to look down and keep your head down. You posture isn't like that of a daughter in law. When she told me this we both knew what her decision should be. But really? This is what we expect? The conclusive and final goal for a girl is getting married and since the time she is born, her upbringing needs to be such that she becomes a "good wife" who tends the house and raise kids. And do we ever think what kind of children she is going to raise if her only mission in life was to get married, if she was never told the importance of learning, never told or was rather discouraged to speak for herself? How can she raise balanced minds when hers was made to tilt in one direction? How can we have a positive society when almost half the population has been robbed of their happiness?  Aren't we setting ourselves up for failure? Should we not be worried about this lop sided society we are trying to create with this imbalance? When will we wake up to this fact that if a girl holds the rolling pin, its not just to please her in laws or her husband, cooking could be her passion, or she may want to become a chef! While grooming herself, she may become interested in being a make up artist or a fashion designer, she might be weaving a dream of being an athlete....or for all its worth, she may want to lead a non professional life of a homemaker but these need to be her aspirations and not imposed on her by anyone, she needs to grow up with a respect for her desires and aspirations and we need to be the instrument for that growth. And for any of these to come true, we need to realize that getting married is a part of her life and not her life. She is not for Show and Tell, she is an entity, a person, a mind and a heart. And the day we all recognize and in fact appreciate this bottom line, then we can end the story with .......and they lived happily ever after. 

16 comments:

  1. Thats the sad part abt our idiotic shows today...treatin women like sm cattle.......

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sheesh! This is indeed one of the worst trailers I get to c in b/w Indian Idol!!!!
    And to add to that, there's also a part in this one saying Hum ladka dekhne nahi, ladki dikhane jaa rahe hai .. filth!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yeah! We females are worth nothing from birth to death in India! Ain't that nice?!
    If my daughter sees this promo, she would say "What a great culture! Yikes!". That's the reason why I didn't let them watch Indian movies when they were young, so they don't think we are all like that in India. Society has changed I hope from this to better attitude towards female kids now, atleast a tad.
    As grown ups now, my kids get curious, stop and watch Hindi movies for a while when I am watching. My son once asked "Do Indian girls dress like strippers in India?" looking at Kareena dancing in teeny weeny short shorts in "Tashan". I said "NOOOO, they don't. It's just in the movies" :D

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous8:43 AM

    "How can she raise balanced minds when hers was made to tilt in one direction?" Bravo! What a powerful statement! I understand your frustration, but if it's any consolation, this phenomenon is not partial to India.

    When I traveled back to Mexico after four years in hotel management school in Switzerland, a client of my father's asked what I had majored in. When I told him, he said: "Ah, yes, a very appropriate career for a woman, so she can learn to cook and clean and serve her husband's friends." I graduated third in my class and went on to run my own successful business, but for him - and countless others - it was all about my potential as a future wife.

    ReplyDelete
  5. To sadly say, this community still exists in India where girls are "paraya dhan" and need to be guarded till they get married....
    very sad indeed.... as you say... how will this person be able to bring up a kid if she herself still remains a kid without any knowledge about the outside... Truly questions which cross everyone's mind but then nothing happens to uplift the plight of such girls....

    ReplyDelete
  6. Goodness! And the saddest thing is, that these notions will be endorsed by millions of us :( Where a woman has no identity beyond being a good daughter, good wife, good daughter in law - which can be achieved only by submitting to the wishes of whoever 'governs' her :(

    You know, the day after my wedding, I was told by husband's 10 year old cousin sis, that I am not behaving like a good bahu - apparently, I was talking too much. I was stunned by the fact that
    1. a 10 year old is given the freedom to talk like this - simply because she was talking to the new bahu - who, of course, can be asked anything..
    2. The ideas that a 10 year old had already gathered..

    And serials like these, just reinforce these ideas even more. That a woman should know her place, all she should do is try and look beautiful, learn to cook, and let her self be made a spectacle of, during the 'bride-seeing'!!! It is so annoying, to say the least!
    I am sure, this piece of junk will be lapped up by millions and also be shown to their daughter/daughter-in-laws to reinstate how they should behave :( One of the biggest reasons, I refuse to switch on any hindi channel - my own mode of protest :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. Bias bias and only bias... and yes I've vent my anger too..http://pinashpinash.blogspot.com/2010/02/oh-still-no-match-for-ur-daughter.html

    Channels instead of being progressive and becoming regressive day by day! why? why don't ppl want to change or is it only TRP that matters??

    Disgusted!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I so agree with this one..And I too had these thoughts when this promo started being aired..sad but that's what we are showing our society !

    ReplyDelete
  9. Didn't expect this post from you. Seems so much below your standard!

    ReplyDelete
  10. The thing that I don't understand is "how come veteran actress like those in the trailer agree to do such filthy roles?" They are the ones who broke all the chains to get into the movie industry and made their own path in life.

    Now everyone will watch it and give it a high TRP. it sucks and you and Smitha have said it so well.

    You have a knack of writing about such topics. Brilliant! and yeah I don't think keeping our kids away from the vices of culture is goona make them less of an Indian. :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. The ad sounds to me as if by highlighting it, the serialmakers are trying to raise awareness against this vice present in our society..

    ReplyDelete
  12. @mayank: we have a long way to go!
    @Swaram: Bothers me every time I hear it!
    @Asha: what they show in movies has to be taken in with what persona they are trying to portray though! I believe in exposing kids to our culture all the while helping them make their own views and standpoints. They see it or not, it does exist!
    @MM:A women is only a potential wife and if she can't cook, she can't be that too! men all over the world are chefs, so that means its not appropriate for them?
    @Shilpa: "paraya dhan"......first she belongs to dad and then to her husband but never to herself!
    @Smitha: A 10 year old dictating you because you are a new DIL!! She has learnt by observation that anything can be said to a DIL and she will bear it with a smile! I keep waiting for one show to come up that I can watch........until today I have nothing in my viewfinder!
    @PNA: Pls give the link again, its not working! And yes TRP is over and above everything I guess!
    @NU: It does look like that there are many who would endorse the show!
    @Sakshi: You have raised a great point Sakshi, after fighting their battles, these actors are now just about themselves!
    @Giribala: how?:-)
    @

    ReplyDelete
  13. Smiths, a 10 yr old! I so wish she comes out of such thinking :(
    I am such a bad bahu by these standards :P :P

    ReplyDelete
  14. I hope this show is about the girl rebelling against such notions. The video did seem to mock the stupid ideas...

    ReplyDelete
  15. Ah, regressive ideas that find a foothold in our society even today!!

    Like IHM said lets hope its a serial about a girl standing up against the very backward mindset.

    ReplyDelete
  16. As IHM says...it seems like a mockery. Because of the exaggeration...

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for stopping by my blog. Your comments are welcome and appreciated