May 17, 2010

Dreams Unlimited

I recently started watching Indian Idol, as much as the antics of Annu Malik bother me, the show does make feel closer to India.  The songs are the ones I grew up with, songs to the tunes  of which I did my first dance, songs that remind of fresher parties in college, songs that remind of my dating days,songs that remind of my childhood,  songs that bring me home. It's gratifying to devour such songs while being so far away from home. So there, since I have explained  the reasons that help me tolerate the ludicrous judge, let's move on from the judges to the contestants.  Actually to their answer to a particular question. 
                     
  "Why do you want to be the Indian Idol?" 
 And here the answers in no particular order:
               1.Its my mom's dream.
               2.Its my dad's dream
               3.Its my mom and dad's dream
                                                           Out of the millions of hopefuls that came for the auditions only a handful had a reason outside of the one's mentioned above. Does this say anything about us as a society? As parents? Many of us, as parents, try to manifest our dream through our children. And in this quest of our own unfulfilled dream, we tend to make the child believe that this is what he/she wants for herself and that we are supporting his/her aspirations. Its not just Indian Idol where we see this. In fact, it's one of the serious issues that children face when making a career decision. Adults tend to completely ignore the fact that the child is free to make his own career choice and in fact might have already made one.  A person needs guidance from parents while exploring the desired career options. Because of their life experiences they might know more about those professions than the child. However, after outlining the ins and outs, shouldn't the child in question be free to do what he wants to do with that information?? 
                              There is one particular contestant on Indian Idol, who was in the final 16 but was not sure if he will go further in the next round. Standing on the stage he had only one thing to say "Mom and Dad, please understand that I have and am working very hard to realize your dream but if I don't get audience's positive response, please remember that I will go on working for your dream" And tears rolled down his cheeks. Do you sense the magnitude of pressure he is under?? 
                  But why? If we have this confidence that we have raised our children well, we have kept the communication channels open with them, if we have impressed them with values of right and wrong, shouldn't we be able to entrust them in making this choice? Some people assert that given a free hand in this life impacting decision, the children would end up choosing some career that would not be fitting. But fitting to which mold? If its your desire that the child becomes a doctor, you would have envisioned him in that doctor coat every time he came home with the report card. And no matter what he wants to become now, it would not fit in that mold of your fancy!! 
                Maria Montessori says, "to give a child liberty is not to abandon him to himself or neglect him. The help we give must not amount to a passive indifference to all the difficulties he will encounter; rather we must support his development with prudent and affectionate care"
                             By providing the right guidance and a positive environment in the formative years, we should be able to trust our children to make informed decisions about their careers. But compelling them to become something we would love them to be isn't exactly being judicious. Every hopeful who was rejected after the audition was heart broken not because he/she couldn't make it but because mummy and papa will be sad that their child failed to actualize their dream.  
                              When we become parents, we see our children as our very own extension, an addendum to the whole. It is hard to perceive that the child as an individual, who is separate from us and is really not here to dance to our tunes. He has an entity of his own, an entity that can have desires that clash with our aspirations. As parents, one of our important roles is to orient ourselves with the insider information about our children's strengths and weaknesses, likes and dislikes, passions and indifference. 
                            To quote Maria Montessori once more "Adults look upon a child as something empty that is to be filled through their own efforts, as something inert and helpless for which they must do everything, as something lacking an inner guide and in constant need of inner direction. . . . An adult who acts in this way, even though he may be convinced that he is filled with zeal, love, and a spirit of sacrifice on behalf of his child, unconsciously suppresses the development of the child's own personality"
So as parents are we not entitled to weave dreams for our children? Say's who? Fabricating dreams for the future is what keeps us hopeful towards life. How wonderful would it be if we envisage for our children, for them to be able to realize their own potential, for them to be able to live their dream and being contended and happy!!





19 comments:

  1. People really need to see 3 idiots more and more...
    When will people stop putting enforcing their dreams and visions on their kids...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh I so wanted to do a post on these lines when I saw a Mom who fainted when her son did not make it to the final round in some dance competition .. and for heaven's sake, the boy is still 6 :( Hw r we even preparing him for the long battle called life? U don't win once and u r nothing .. Y can't u applaud him for his participation and teach him its ok if someone got better .. we will work better next time. When will we learn not to take failure to our heart and just whine abt it :( :(

    ReplyDelete
  3. So true with Indian society which makes me sad. Even little Kindergartners go thru' lot of anxiety and fear there about school. My nephew is just 7yrs old, he gets very scared and tensed to go to school although he makes good grades and he is so chatty and happy at home. There are few websites where they curse the schools and principals only when their kids don't get in but praise the school if they are in. Teenagers are under tremendous pressure to achieve too.
    Great post S.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Really good post and what ever you said that is 100% real.recently i saw an article regarding this topic in www.chennaimoms.com here many moms shared their opinion ,you also check it out and give your comments.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Parents should really stop putting pressure on kids, and vicariously living their dreams through them. Seriously. I feel even more irritated when they send little kids to reality shows and put pressure on them!

    ReplyDelete
  6. @Shilpa: 3 idiots brought this issue on the spotlight but I am sure many who enjoyed the movie, only did that and didn't take any lesson home.
    @Swaram: Those competitions for little ones are far more damaging to say the least!! read the post Chinkurli did on the same topic.http://chinkurli.wordpress.com/2010/05/03/why-i-am-not-a-fan-of-kids-on-reality-tv/
    @Asha: Tremendous pressure to achieve but only what elders want and not what they want for themselves!
    @anu: Welcome here!
    @Chinkurli:vicariously living their dreams through them You said it! Loved your post about kids reality show.

    ReplyDelete
  7. We were discussing this at home last night. It is so sad to see parents pushing their dreams on to their children and trying to live their dreams through the child. It is so sad, that children are not considered important enough when it comes to deciding what they want to do. Even more so, when it involves competitions like this where a defeat could scar a child for life, esp when they know how much their parents want them to win..

    And the sad thing is, that it is so very common :( People all around seem to be doing it.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anonymous12:53 PM

    nice post Sandhya! ow can you get such a deep meaning out of everyday simple things...expert blogger you are:) As some one said here-we need to watch 3 idiots more and more...

    ReplyDelete
  9. @Smitha: It is very common and hence seems the right thing to do!!
    @Mithe: Welcome back!!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Anonymous11:44 PM

    Wonderful post. I think this is common everywhere in the world. Here I see parents enrolling their kids in all kinds of stuff be it karate, Soccer, Swimming, Ballet and what not. I think the child is never asked the question "What is that you want to do after school?". It's a mad race to fulfil the dreams of the parents and unfortunately the the dreams are enforced the moment the baby is born

    ReplyDelete
  11. @CC: It is considered very trendy to say "we have this class and then this and then that one, we are busy all weekend" It is a rat race to reach somewhere where the traveler (child) doesn't even want to go!!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi!

    This is a very well written post and touches many points that parents should really be able to understand. Its great to read your blog and we would like to invite you to write for us and you can get featured too!

    It can be about better parenting, importance of fun & learning or your thoughts on our Indian education system.

    So what are you waiting for? The thoughts are in your head, the keyboard is in front of you. Get going!

    Send in your write-ups at: writeforus@educationisinsurance.com

    Regards,
    Education is Insurance

    ReplyDelete
  13. "...for them to be able to live their dream and being contended and happy!!" and for us to live our dreams--other ones besides raising children--and be contended and happy too.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This is a nicely written post. People are already mad. They want their child to be at the top. Forcing them in EVERYTHING!

    I, with my mates, have been recently discuss about this. And all of us were actually saddened about it, and the fact all of us had some or the other story to share on the similar stuff; which shows at what speed this disease is spreading around!

    Also, I hate losers who say - I am doing this because of blah blah's dreams. Fuck it up, man! When will you do it for YOUR OWN dream?

    ReplyDelete
  15. well said already! mirrored my thoughts on the subject!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Basically parents in India feel they know what's best for an adult child or even a middle aged child. What kind of parents would teach their child that it good to give up one's own happiness for one's parents?

    A child who thinks for himself (mainly boys, but girls also) is seen as selfish and uncaring :| This reflects in our overall attitude towards parenting.

    ReplyDelete
  17. @Giribala: That's right when we parents start living our life and shift our focus from kids to other things in life it will be better for all of us.
    @The Virgin Author: Rightly said!! usually those who lose tend to cry and say its for someone else!
    @Chandni: It is so nice to see you here!! Welcome!!
    @IHM: We really should get a mandatory lesson in parenting before having kids!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Nicely written post. This reminds me of a cricket-mom who slapped her kid (a boy) for getting out LBW in a match. She said, "who asked you to play that on backfoot?"

    ReplyDelete
  19. @Raja: OMG!! That actually happened???

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for stopping by my blog. Your comments are welcome and appreciated